Showing posts with label skills. Show all posts
Showing posts with label skills. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 17, 2017

Class-based vs. Skill-based

The Northern Realm as a game is intended to provide a visceral experience and flexible character building. Having classes and levels, however, doesn't lend itself to creating completely unique characters. The obvious alternative is to ixnay the classes and create a complete skill based system. So I went for it, I spent a day organizing a list of skills and untangling the classes. Then I took a big step back and looked at it. I didn't like it. I want it to be customizable, but the classes are too much to dump. What I did though, is break the classes down into three archetypes and then laid out rules for creating characters. How'd I do?



An archetype provides an overall framework for what a character is capable of. There are three general archetypes– the specialist, the mixed bag, and the spellcaster. Under each of these are a number of unique expressions of the archetype, referred to as classes. These classes may be modified to better suit your character concept, following the rules provided by each archetype.

Skills and Attributes: All characters are provided with 3 skills per level, which may be modified due to their choice in race. Archetypes may add or subtract from this number. For example, a character with the Specialist archetype gains one extra skill at each level, whereas one with the Spellcaster archetype gains one less skill at each level.

Classes provide attributes, special abilities unique to that class. However, gaining the attribute reduces the amount of skills gained at that level by one. You may always choose not to gain an attribute and thus not reduce the amount of skills gained. For example, a half-blooded character who chooses the specialist archetype begins with 4 skills (3 provided as a base, plus one from the specialist archetype). If he then decides to play as a barbarian and gain the Rage attribute, his skills are reduced by 1, leaving him with 3 skills to spend as he chooses. ________________________________________________________________________________
Specialists are the explorers, tradesmen, and warriors. They may have some supernatural abilities but are unable to cast spells. Specialists have high Acumen and each level gain +1 skill.

Mixed Bag
characters rely on skills and spellcasting. They gain only partial spellcasting abilities. In exchange, choose either high or low Acumen. If you choose low Acumen, gain 3 skills per level as normal, otherwise, gain 1 less skill each level. Or, if the class appeals to you but you do not require spellcasting abilities, drop them to retain a high Acumen and gain +1 skill each level.

Spellcasters dedicate their lives to the arcane. They gain a full range of spellcasting abilities. All spellcasters have low Acumen and gain 1 less skill each level.
________________________________________________________________________________

Example skills:

Armed Grappler:
While grappling, you can make 1 extra attack per round with a light weapon. Make grapple checks in place of attack checks and roll for damage with each successful check.

Fortitude: You have built up an incredible constitution. When bleeding out, you may spend 1 Power to stave off death for 1d6 rounds.

Example Class:



Additional Player's Handbook Update: I've added a little art to the handbook and it doesn't look too shabby.

Thursday, October 20, 2016

Skills part 2, a marriage of feats and ability scores

I've had many a long discussion about the difference between feats and skills. In the end, I always ended up being the only defender of the system, arguing feats were a subset of specific skills, essentially a skill within a skill. But it's always bothered me that I kept it the same way as D&D for the first version of Northern Realm and the longer I thought about it the more I agreed with my friends, it doesn't really make sense to have two different ways of getting bonuses for skills.

For version 2 of the Northern Realm, I did away with feats, figuring that class abilities would make each character unique. But after some testing, it ended up making character creation less unique. For months my friends and I have been discussing what to do with skills. First I added an aspect to skills where players can distribute skill ranks in-game (rather than during creation). It made for some interesting results. Then I added a few skills that essentially granted feats if you put enough skill ranks into them. Ultimately, it was after looking at a new character sheet for Northern Realm that it  hit me, take away skill ranks. Make all checks ability score checks. Then create a list of skills for each ability score. Whenever something pertains to that skill, like Stealth, use that modifier instead. It doesn't seem that terribly different, but after looking at it written down, it was much easier to follow. And not only that, simpler and for each character more unique. Here it is as described in the book:

Skills
Skills represent your ability to perform actions that you have trained, practiced, or studied for. At level 1, choose 3 skills. At level 2 and on, you may choose 3 additional skills, which you may select at any time before your next level. Once a skill is chosen it cannot be changed later.

Dexterity
Armed Grapple: While grappling, you can make 1 extra attack per round with a light weapon. Make grapple checks in place of attack checks and roll for damage with each successful check.
Blind-Fight: In a melee, each time you miss because of concealment, reroll the miss chance to see if you hit. Further, you are not automatically caught Flat-Footed against unseen targets (you can still be caught Flat-Footed when flanked or taken from the rear)......

Intellect
Engineering: You know how to construct or disarm a trap, sabotage or build a mechanical device, pick locks, break lock combinations, and solve complex puzzles built into contraptions. With this skill, double your Intellect modifier on checks pertaining to engineering.
Heal: You've stitched wounds, you have knowledge of healing herbs, helped others recover from injuries and sickness, you can determine the cause of an affliction, antidotes, and create balms and remedies to treat patients. With this skill, double your Intellect modifier on checks pertaining to healing.
Incantations: Each time you choose incantations as a skill, select 2 from the following list: Arcane Mark, Clean Wound, Dancing Lights, Daybreak, Detect Magic, Divining Wand, Flare,... 


And so on.

Lastly, I made Knowledge and Perception their own metric.



Knowledge

Every character has knowledge that pertains to their skills. If a Knowledge check would relate to your class or background, roll 1d20 + Intellect modifier + class level; taken together is your Knowledge bonus).

Perception

Perception is your ability to notice objects, movements, sounds, or search for items. The GM should constantly roll secret Perception checks to notice things (we recommend rolling even when there is nothing to notice to keep players on their toes). A Perception check is 1d20 + Intuition modifier + Acumen; taken together is your Perception bonus).


So far it's worked out quite well. Thoughts? 

Wednesday, September 21, 2016

Incorporating Skills and Villainizing Feats

I've posed the question, what game best uses skills on multiple forums over the past couple weeks and received some great responses. From utilizing approaches to skill actions (instead of rolling) to making every aspect of a character building skill-based, there is a lot out there. One constant, however, is at least one or two offhanded statements about how D&D's skill system was 'tacked on.' This is a pretty strong theme in internet communities populated with avid RPG player, be it a complaint about feats, saves, bonuses- a large portion of long-time RPG players seem not only reject the D&D system but also scoff at its design.

I tend to think this is due to exposure to many RPG systems and more of a rejection of the norm (maybe even crave for something new) than a true condemnation of the whole system. With that said, I did pose the question for a reason. I took the system from 3.5 and simply pared down the amount of skills and ranks, and called it a day. My reasoning for keeping it was that at the time it seemed pretty damn customizable. But eventually, I came back to it (as I do with everything) and made a second adjustment (and probably the most pronounced) and changed what many of the skills were. I'm particularly happy with dropping Charisma based skills like Bluff and Intimidate in favor of Composure because it necessitates a verbal response from the character before the roll, instead of taking the Exalted path and using skills like attacks.

After this second revision, I left it only to return again, because what truly bothers me about the system is that it's cumbersome for the character creation process. You have to look through many lists to make your character; skills, feats, classes, races, spells. If I want to have classes then there's no avoiding a list of those, and having different races and spells are simply a necessity as well, but  I can get rid of one list, feats. I've always had trouble justifying their existence. How are they different from skills? It also doesn't help that old school players utterly reject them. And even though that doesn't bother me too much, It suddenly hit me, just combine skills and feats. Right now I have ranks in Spellcraft granting characters access to 0 level spells. Well, I could just take this a step further and strip away 'skill ranks' and 'skill points' and simply state, with a skill modifier of such and such choose 2 features from the spellcraft skill or martial focus skill. The only difficulty here is marrying the two ideas in such a way that I'm not left with a mess.

With that out there, it begs the question, how do players increase the character's skill modifier later in the game? My first instinct was to have the GM grant permanent skill modifier bonuses based on the player's actions. In fact, I parsed it all out until a friend said, are you really going to be doing that consistently in the game or is it just going to become this forgotten thing? So I thought, what about having the player grant his character a higher skill modifier, let's say to a maximum bonus of +3, either divided into many skills or lumped into one skill. Now, I assume the player or GM (or both) will dream up an in-game reason, like the character spent a lot of time at the arcane library trying to solve this mystery, so his Knowledge Sorcery increases by 1, but either way, with a maximum value, it's a recognizable mechanic that gives the player a choice, spend it here or here based on the story. I think it's an eloquent solution, no?

Saturday, September 17, 2016

Ability Scores

The most common ability scores are strength, dexterity, constitution, charisma, intelligence, and wisdom, or some variation on them, like swapping constitution with vitality. For the Northern Realm, I began with the same ability scores but found it harder and harder to justify constitution. It seems like strength should have that covered. Could someone with a high strength really have a low constitution?

Then there's charisma. You see arguments crop up on forums about skills like bluff and diplomacy, and inevitably it becomes a shouting match between lawyers and 'What happened to role-playing!' I admit, I fall into the latter somewhat, but I'm realizing that if I want to encourage role-playing it should be built into the game. Step one, break up the mental statistics. Wisdom covered too much anyway, so I landed on intellect, intuition, and will. Second, no saves. The thought is, this will help spread out the importance of each ability score. Last, pare down the skills and associate them with players' words and actions, eg. composure.

Then there's luck. What I've noticed with alternative systems are they include things like faith, spirit, and the like. But with the underlying fairytale theme, luck felt like the natural choice, it also feels more like an inherent trait.

So next step, make all ability scores relevant for all characters- or at least useful. That means no dump stats. To make it work, the first thing to do is get rid of proficiencies. Classes already have specific abilities, they don't need to be railroaded into an archetype, right? If I want a smart fighter, why not? Next, tie each one to something important. Dexterity to attacks, initiative, and AC, strength to attacks and life, intellect to the number of spells known and important skills, including one that grants access to spells (even to non-spellcasters), intuition to cantrips, initiative, and perception, will to power and concentration, and last, luck to spell resistance and bonus dice.

It doesn't exactly make the mental stats as important for combat oriented classes, but it does make them viable. Plus, a bonus to initiative, possible spells, power for abilities, and the skills perception and engineering are still pretty damn important. And an added bonus, spellcasters are clearly the most powerful characters in all rpgs, so the very foundation of spellcasters is built on a balancing act of ability scores. All are important to them. Hopefully that means each spellcaster will come out unique without having to rely on a supermix of different classes and prestige classes.

Ultimately that's the goal, balance. The more eloquent the better. I want to avoid arbitrary rules that limit characters. Leaving it up to the players seems like the best way to do that, right?